SF Giants Left Field is Not Right

posted in: Baseball | 0

During the off season, the Giants did well to sign a bonafide closer in Mark Melancon. Their bull pen was their most glaring weakness throughout the 2016 season. This was capped with a blown 9th inning 5-2 lead to the Cubs in the 4th game of the NLDS. Matt Moore had thrown a masterpiece for 8 innings holding the Cubs to 2 hits with 10 strikeouts. The bull pen meltdown allowing the Cubs to score 4 runs in the 9th was a microcosm of their entire season. With Johnny Cueto scheduled to pitch the final game of the series, Giant fans had high hopes that they could advance to the World Series again keeping their every-other-year title chances intact. This was before the fateful 9th inning meltdown.

The 2017 season, although very early, is revealing another flaw. The Giants plan to platoon Jarrett Parker and Chris Marerro in Left Field has not worked out. Parker made a great catch but crashed his shoulder into the wall and broke his collar bone. He will be out for 2-3 months. Marerro is batting .133 and Aaron Hill hasn’t fared much better.

I’m sure that Brian Sabean and Bobby Evans are looking at all options. If things don’t improve in the next few weeks, I’m thinking that they will have to make some moves. Two options that I favor are:

  • Trade for Ryan Braun. Braun will achieve 10-and-5 rights on May 24, thus allowing him full veto power over any trade (10 years in the Bigs and 5 years on the same team). The Brewers may feel some sense of urgency to make a trade before May 24 if they are in re-build mode. This makes sense for two reasons. Braun can fill the gap in Left and has power. The other reason is that the Dodgers may make a play on him as their record against left-handed pitchers is atrocious. They are also looking for a right-handed power bat.
  • Bring up Christian Arroyo and play him at 3rd base, then move Eduardo Nunez to Left Field. Arroyo is batting .479 and is the Giant’s top prospect. During his limited time in the Bigs, he has shown an ability to square up the ball and hit line drives. Nunez has plenty of speed to cover the left field but he has limitations as he is trained as an infielder. Please keep in mind that this is a temporary solution until Mac Williamson’s quad get healed. I’m thinking that this could very well take 2 months as he’ll need a month of minor league play to get back into the groove. I like the Arroyo and Nunez moves as both are hitti

I’m sure Sabean and Evans are looking at other options but hoping that they make Left Field right.